Retrofuture.com

Where Yesterday’s Tomorrow Is Still the Future.

Will Virtual Dogs Replace Man’s Best Friend?

I haven’t heard much about AIBO in the ten years since this article was published.

dog3For most of the 20th Century, we’ve been hearing about the arrival of a robot dog—a docile and obedient machine which never has an accident on the rug, never barks at the postman, and never mounts the legs of stranger in inappropriate ways.

Finally, this year, in a blaze of publicity, Sony announced it had created the legendary machine—a fully autonomous “entertainment robot” named AIBO.

Equipped with a 180,000 pixel camera (hidden in its nose) and an infrared distance sensor to detect objects, AIBO is programmed to climb stairs and sing songs. Best of all, it never blows you away with dog breath.

dog6bSony says it developed AIBO with “the aim of bringing human and robots closer together.” But, thus far, the bark hasn’t lived up to the byte. Most people still prefer the company of their imperfect, non-mechanical dogs and cats.

Nevertheless, AIBO does represent a significant leap forward in the development of autonomous robots as a commercial venture.

And judging from brisk sales (a limited-edition run of 5000 robot dogs was snapped up almost instantaneously by collectors last summer at $2500 a pop), AIBO is here to stay. Robot enthusiasts expect more breeds to follow.

dog2Although the role of man’s best friend seems secure for the time being, historically speaking, the emergence of AIBO and other robots could change their vaunted status.

Just as a horse was associated with strength (aka, horsepower) until automobiles came along, it’s plausible that the loyalty of a dog could be replaced by the affection of a robot.

AIBO is designed to ingratiate itself to its human masters by replicating the precise traits of a dog (like wagging its tail) while creating new ways of communication (musical tones, colored lights in its eyes). Furthermore, owners can rest assured that AIBO will not bite the hand that feeds it (at least not intentionally).

dog4Like R2-D2 and C-3PO in Star Wars, AIBO is designed to be a benevolent machine. Models are equipped with a touch sensor that allow owners to administer affection as well as discipline if warranted.

“Pet AIBO gently to tell it that you are happy,” instructs a Sony press release, “(or give it) a little smack on the head and AIBO will understand that you are scolding it.”

AIBO’s sophisticated programming allows it to “think and feel for itself,” its creators claim, with “instincts” and “emotions” like a real dog.

The question is: when, if ever, will advanced machine intelligence begin to replace the “pure bred” dogs and cats we know and love? Nolan Bushnell (the “father” of Atari and Chuckie Cheese) was once asked this question back in the early 1980s when he was marketing one of the first commercially marketed home robots called Brains on Board (or BOB).

dog5Asked about what effect BOB would have on dogs, Bushnell joked, “They’ll become curiosities, like old cars.”

But as fate would have it, it was BOB (left) who became a curiosity. As Bushnell found out, there is no guarantee that people will automatically open their doors to a robot, no matter how human (or dog-like) they appear to be.

Will AIBO suffer the same fate as BOB? Will it become just the latest in a long line of novelty robots? History is already littered with dead-tech prototypes with names like Cosmo, Klatuu, Dottie, and Hero.

AIBO may fare better than its robotic ancestors if early indications are anymeasure. Perhaps it will even give birth to mechanical offspring in the future.

dog1Real dogs? Their loyalty is not in question. But ours is. In the end, if we betray man’s best friend, we might be staring at the nuts and bolts of our own obsolescence.

Tags:

4 Responses to “Will Virtual Dogs Replace Man’s Best Friend?”

  1. Moondragon007 says:

    To be any real competition to live dogs and cats, a robot would have to be fuzzy and cuddly, and most of all, it would have to be able to love you. I know my cat loves me, she meows a good morning to me when I wake up, and waits by the door for me when I come home.

  2. Known as “The Dogfather” in the virtual world Second Life,as well as in real life, I am Vitolo Rossini. I invite you to explore the Vitrtual world of 2nd Life, and to come to see me!
    I own the VKC Dog Park at Canis Beach in the region of Rhoda. This has become the largest and most popular dog park in the virtual world of Second Life.
    Owning and working with one of these dogs, can be the most rewarding experience you have ever had, in a computer “metaverse”. At my dog park my philosophy is “you bought a dog… you will get respect!”. We go out of our way at Canis Beach to make certain that all of your virtual dog needs are met 24/7.
    Come and see me, and let me walk you through the experience of a lifetime!
    The dogs are always getting new exciting features, and are true artificial intelligence , and can learn and develop as you do. This enhances your virtual experience to such an extent, that the great confidence you build carries over into your daily life. Success, after all begets further success, and I make sure all Virtual Dog experiences are successful ones.
    I do not only work with VKC Dogs. I direct in world Services for All D&D Dog locations as well, and I provide consultation and assistance with any SL dog.
    It is time for you to come and try Second Life. It is easily downloaded, and is a virtual world with endless possibilities! Once there contact me. For more info Google my name, or contact me through this Website!

  3. Babbie J says:

    I think that REAL dogs are the most loyal animal that we have and if we betray them, then what would really happen? Another extinct spieces? I believe that a real pet is much better. Even if these things have their own abilities, nothing will be able to compete with the original, loving animals that we know so much. But it is a matter of opinion. I still hope that people don’t forget about how much these animals mean to us. They were the first animals that we domesticated and used and they have forever been faithful and we should return that. My dog is like me in so many ways and we know what each other feels, she knows when im sad and i know when she is sad. Shes like me only a dog. They may be the same, but how many robo dogs are gonna come up and comfort you when you are crying or “listen” when you had a bad day? not many. You learn responsibility from pets. When you are little and you get a puppy, you have to feed it and water it every 2 times a day. This has always been a “tradition”. The average American family is symbolized as a dog named Spot playing with his owners Dick and Jane. This is all personally my opinion of course so feel free to choose your own way, but please dont forget our true friends, the ones with since we started to evolve!!!!!!

  4. following this blog, good stuff!

Leave a Reply